Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shellie Enteen's avatar

Thanks for that deep dive. I dind't know at the time but I read somewhere that Paul wrote it for Julian due to the Yoko entry and divorce, but I don't know who he (Julian) found to go out and get or perfom with. Or whether he was contemplating drugs...could have been. But it was his father doing the heroin as I learned in my NYC days from tarot people who worked for Yoko. The first line...take a sad song and make it better. This was a sad song for all of us when Yoko arrived on the scene. I remember how upset we fans were. She wasn't liked very much, even when they were doing the bed-in. I think the chantint at the end made this a classic. I remember seeing a live group performance and once they got there to singalong their faces lit up and there were big smiles. Nah Nah Nah...ahs for the heart chakra. This isnt the small studio audience I saw but this really shows the chant https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRnFHfI7WAQ

Leslie Orsini's avatar

I learned something here. I had always dismissed "Hey Jude" as a sappy and much-too-long love song. I mean. what did I care if Jude were to "let it out and let in" as opposed to if he were to "let it in and let it out"? It's Jude's problem, not mine. He ought to know better than to let some object of his fancy take such a hold on him. But after reading Gargatholil's take, I admit I was wrong. The song uses "love" or sexual attraction, which everybody -- except possibly Jesus, Judas, and Thomas Aquinas -- has experienced, as a universal touchstone to make a point anyone can grapple with: One has to experience the real universe and understand the difference between illusion and truth to truly live. The real world is not the phony allure of a libidinous calling. It's is a subtle world we must comprehend beyond the tawdry illusion of the five senses. Point taken. I still could have used a minute less of the "na-na-na-na-na-na"s.

No posts

Ready for more?